Today's Date: March 29, 2024
Jamieson Wellness Publishes Inaugural Sustainability Impact Report   •   Make-A-Wish and celebrity wish granters announce goal to recruit 1 million people to become "WishMakers"   •   Carnegie Learning Named 2024 SIIA CODiE Award Finalist for Best Educational Game and Best AI Implementation in Ed Tech   •   Parkland Corporation Announces the Results of the 2024 Annual General Meeting of Shareholders   •   Midea Group releases its first-ever ESG brand story with an unexpected VIP visit highlighting its commitment to sustainability.   •   National University Receives 2024 Military Friendly® Gold Designation   •   Re:wild and Colossal Biosciences team up to leverage revolutionary technology to save critically endangered species on the brink   •   Equalpride Partners with TransLash Media for Trans Day of Visibility, Amplifying Voices of Black Trans Femmes in the Arts   •   Suffolk Kicks off 2024 “Build With Us @ Suffolk” Program in Boston for Trade Partners, Opening Doors for Minority-,   •   VIRGIN HOTELS CHAMPIONS INCLUSIVE TRAVEL FOR NEURODIVERSE TRAVELERS   •   Chosgo K23: One of the Best Bluetooth Hearing Aids for Seniors   •   Amerex Group Unveils Red Carter Swimwear's Revitalized Collection   •   Coachella Concerned That People Have Sex, Says AHF   •   Visit Visalia Recognizes Autism Awareness Month in April   •   Anaergia Announces Delay in the Filing of Its Audited Financial Statements and Related Disclosures   •   Empire State Realty Trust Receives WELL Health-Safety Leadership Award; Becomes Among the First Commercial Office and Multifamil   •   Anaergia Announces Escrow Closing of Second Tranche of the Strategic Investment   •   Fosun Management on 2023 Annual Results: Focusing on Core Industries with Established Advantages   •   Sypher Secures Strategic Partnership with FAIA to Fuel Growth   •   YMCA of the USA Partners With Old Spice To Increase High School Graduation Among Boys And Young Men Of Color Through Mentorship
Bookmark and Share

Judge Blocks Elimination Of Gay Partner Benefits

PHOENIX, AZ - U.S. District Court Judge John W.
Sedwick today granted Lambda Legal's request for a preliminary injunction
blocking the elimination of domestic partner benefits for gay and lesbian
Arizona State employees. The judge also substantially denied a motion to
dismiss the case by State's Attorney Charles Grube, ordering that the case
proceed on the merits.

Lambda Legal represents ten state employees – including from the Arizona
Highway Patrol, the State Department of Game and Fish, and state
universities – who rely on health benefits from their employers to
safeguard their families' health, as heterosexual workers do.

Sedwick's ruling rejects claims by the state that the elimination of
benefits will not harm the families of gay and lesbian employees because
they may still be able to obtain insurance privately, through Medicaid or
via the employers of the non-public employee partner. "Even assuming that
is true," Sedwick writes, citing a 9th Circuit Court ruling in Lambda
Legal's ongoing case In re Golinski, "the Ninth Circuit has recognized
there is 'an inherent inequality' in allowing some employees to participate
fully in the State's health plan, while expecting other employees to rely
on other sources, such as private insurance or Medicaid. 'This back of
the bus' treatment relegates plaintiffs to a second-class status by
imposing inferior workplace treatment on them, inflicting serious
constitutional and dignitary harms that after-the-fact damages cannot
adequately address."

"This injunction removes the sword that's been hanging over the heads of
hundreds of state workers and their families," said Tara Borelli, the
Lambda Legal staff attorney who argued the case on June 28th. "We're
pleased Judge Sedwick has recognized that this is a matter of equal pay for
equal work, and that eliminating benefits for Arizona's gay and lesbian
state employees would hurt real families."

Sedwick also rejected the State's claims that maintaining the same benefits
for gay employees that their heterosexual co-workers will continue to
receive would endanger other state services: "The State's argument, which
is not supported by any evidence, is speculative at best and discriminatory
at worst. Contrary to the State's suggestion, it is not equitable to lay
the burden of the State's budgetary shortfall on homosexual employees, any
more than on any other distinct class, such as employees with green eyes or
red hair."

Arizona lawmakers included a provision eliminating domestic partner health
benefits for gay state employees as part of a last-minute budget deal
signed by Governor Jan Brewer last September, while retaining spousal
health benefits for heterosexual workers. Today's injunction barring
enforcement of the insurance cut-off will take effect in ten days. The
State can appeal the ruling immediately to the Ninth Circuit Court of
Appeals, or proceed to defend the discriminatory budget provision on the
merits in the District Court.

Lambda Legal Staff Attorney Tara Borelli argued the case, with Jennifer C.
Pizer of Lambda Legal, and Daniel C. Barr, Rhonda L. Barnes and Kirstin T.
Eidenbach of the law firm of Perkins, Coie, Brown & Bain P.A. as
co-counsel. The case is Collins v. Brewer.


Lambda Legal is a national organization committed to achieving full
recognition of the civil rights of lesbians, gay men, bisexuals,
transgender people and those with HIV through impact litigation, education
and public policy work.



Back to top
| Back to home page
Video

White House Live Stream
LIVE VIDEO EVERY SATURDAY
alsharpton Rev. Al Sharpton
9 to 11 am EST
jjackson Rev. Jesse Jackson
10 to noon CST


Video

LIVE BROADCASTS
Sounds Make the News ®
WAOK-Urban
Atlanta - WAOK-Urban
KPFA-Progressive
Berkley / San Francisco - KPFA-Progressive
WVON-Urban
Chicago - WVON-Urban
KJLH - Urban
Los Angeles - KJLH - Urban
WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
New York - WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
WADO-Spanish
New York - WADO-Spanish
WBAI - Progressive
New York - WBAI - Progressive
WOL-Urban
Washington - WOL-Urban

Listen to United Natiosns News