Plaintiff’s trial team includes Greene Broillet & Wheeler, LLP, Scherr Law Firm, and California Truck Injury Law
EL SEGUNDO, Calif., Nov. 19, 2026 /PRNewswire/ — A Los Angeles County jury recently awarded a $21.9 million verdict in a case arising from a devastating collision between a passenger vehicle and a Consolidated Disposal Services LLC garbage truck in the north valley of Los Angeles. The November 2019 crash claimed the life of 18-year-old passenger Sebastien “Bash” Gallegos and left 18-year-old passenger Angel Sanchez with a permanent traumatic brain injury. The driver of the Acura involved in the crash, 18-year-old Eugne Oh was also killed.
After a two-month trial in Chatsworth, Angel Sanchez and the Gallegos family secured the $21.9 million jury verdict.
Beyond the immeasurable loss suffered by the families, the trial brought renewed attention to important safety issues involving rear underride guards that are supposed to be installed on large trucks to adequately protect people in today’s passenger vehicles.
The plaintiffs’ trial team included Greene Broillet & Wheeler, LLP partners Bruce Broillet and Alan Van Gelder, co-counsel Maxey Scherr of Scherr Law Firm and Kate Harvey-Lee of California Truck Injury Law.
“Nothing about this case can undo what these families have been through,” said Bruce Broillet, co-lead trial attorney and partner at GBW. “We wanted the jury to understand the full human impact of this crash, but also to look closely at the safety issues that contributed to the tragedy. We hope this verdict helps bring greater attention to the protections people should be able to expect when sharing the road with large commercial trucks.”
A central issue at trial was the truck’s rear underride guard, also known as an ICC bar. These guards are designed to prevent passenger vehicles from sliding beneath the rear of a large truck in a collision. These bars are required by State and Federal law to be properly in place and substantially constructed.
During the case, Consolidated Disposal Services (a subsidiary of Republic Services) repeatedly argued that they were not required to have underride guards and that their alleged failure to follow State and Federal law was excused because the laws were out of date and no longer capable of protecting modern passenger sedans.
The Plaintiffs trial team presented evidence showing that the law applied to Consolidated/Republic and that the guards being used by Consolidated/Republic were not compliant with existing law. Evidence was presented that the standards for rear underride guards need to be updated to provide sufficient protection for modern passenger vehicles, and that Consolidated/Republic could not escape liability by claiming the regulations had not been updated.
“Some cases you try. Some cases you carry. I will carry Bash Gallegos, Angel Sanchez and their families with me always,” said Maxey Scherr, co-lead trial attorney and founder of Scherr Law Firm. “People make mistakes in a moment. Safety systems are supposed to keep those moments from becoming tragedies. Federal underride protection requirements date to 1953. This is not a new danger or a new responsibility. I was proud to stand beside these families and fight for a basic principle: corporate shortcuts should never determine who gets to come home.”
Some of the federal safety requirements governing rear underride guards date back decades, when passenger vehicles were built very differently than they are today. The trial raised questions about whether those standards have kept pace with changes in vehicle design and the risks motorists face.
The jury assigned 65% responsibility for the collision to Oh, 20% to Consolidated Disposal, and 15% to the Consolidated truck driver. The jury awarded $15 million to Bash Gallegos’ parents, Kimberly and Alex Gallegos: $7.5 million for their past suffering and an additional $7.5 million for future suffering. Angel Sanchez was awarded $6.9 million, including $500,000 for future lost earning capacity, $400,000 for medical expenses, $1 million for past pain and suffering, and $5 million for future pain and suffering. Together, the awards total $21.9 million.
“For the families, this was really about getting answers and holding a large company responsible so a tragedy like this might be prevented in the future,” said Kate Harvey-Lee of California Truck Injury Law. “The evidence revealed one of the biggest trucking companies in the nation was not meeting its safety obligations and focused attention on how important rear underride guards are in protecting us all. People driving today’s cars should not have to wonder whether the basic safety protections on the trucks around them are adequate.”
Alan Van Gelder, partner at Greene Broillet & Wheeler, LLP, said the case underscores the importance of examining commercial vehicle safety and the standards intended to protect the public.
“The loss of Bash and the devastating injuries Angel sustained, are reminders of the consequences these crashes can have,” Van Gelder said. “We hope the attention surrounding this case encourages a closer look at rear underride guard safety and whether current standards do enough to protect people on our roads. Consolidated and Republic should use this verdict as a wakeup call to change the way they do business.”
Case Name: Gallegos v. Consolidated Disposal Service LLC, dba Republic Services Of Southern California; Los Angeles County Superior Court [Consolidated Case No. 21STCV42588]
View original content:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/21-9-million-verdict-in-crash-involving-three-teens-raises-truck-safety-concerns-302944724.html
SOURCE Greene Broillet & Wheeler, LLP

